CSI in The News

Jewish NYC: History, heritage, Hanukkah — and food

By 
updated 12/8/2011 3:17:56 PM ET

NEW YORK — Museums and historic sites, the world's largest menorah, and a trendy new Tribeca restaurant inspired by an old-school Catskills resort. They're all part of Jewish New York, with a heritage that stretches back 400 years and a vital contemporary community that's reinterpreting old traditions for the 21st century.

New York City has the largest concentration of Jews in the world outside of Israel, according to the Jewish Databank, which put the city's Jewish population at 1.4 million in 2002. The stories of European Jews who arrived in the late 19th and early 20th centuries are relatively well-known and easy to find in places like the Lower East Side. But visitors with an interest in Jewish New York will also want to explore many other parts of the city, from the Jewish Children's Museum in Brooklyn to a 17th century graveyard on a Chinatown sidestreet.

An obvious place to start is Ellis Island, where the ancestors of so many American Jews first set foot on U.S. soil. Boats run from Battery Park — schedules at http://www.statuecruises.com — to the National Park site in New York Harbor. The Ellis Island museum offers a wealth of artifacts connected to Jewish immigrants, including a photo of a kosher kitchen that opened on the island in 1911 and an eye chart with a line of Hebrew letters.

From where the boat lets you off on your return to Manhattan, you can walk to the Museum of Jewish Heritage in Battery Park City. Through summer 2012, the museum is hosting a fascinating exhibit about Emma Lazarus. Lazarus' sonnet "The New Colossus" with its famous line "Give me your tired, your poor, your huddles masses," is engraved on a tablet in the Statue of Liberty's pedestal, and Lady Liberty can be seen from the museum windows. Lazarus was born in New York to an old Sephardic Jewish family; a letter about religious freedom from her great-great uncle to George Washington is part of the show.

The Museum of Jewish Heritage was created as a memorial to those who perished in the Holocaust. Many of its permanent exhibits are related to life before, during and after the Nazi persecution of Jews in Europe during World War II. Admission, $12 (children 12 and under free); closed Saturdays; http://www.mjhnyc.org/.

A little farther uptown you'll find a newcomer restaurant with nostalgic ties to New York's Jewish past. Kutsher's Tribeca, which opened in November at 186 Franklin St., is the brainchild of Zach Kutsher, whose grandparents ran Kutsher's Country Club, a popular Catskills resort in its mid-20th century heyday. The menu reinvents and updates favorite Jewish comfort foods, offering savory brisket meatballs, chopped liver made from duck, and yummy matzo ball soup with dill. You can even order caviar with your latkes — though the roe is not from sturgeon, which isn't kosher. (Kutsher's is not strictly kosher but it does not serve forbidden foods like pork or shellfish.)

Drinks at Kutsher's hark back to fun times at the resort with names like Bungalow Bunny, the term for a wife spending the summer with her kids in the Catkills while her husband worked in the city; and Bug Juice, originally a summer camp drink for kids made from a combination of leftover juices. The restaurant serves dinner from 5:30 p.m. on; beginning Dec. 20, lunch will be served at noon. On Dec. 25, Kutsher's will offer a special Chinese-themed menu in honor of the American Jewish tradition of going out for Chinese food on Christmas Day.

Next, head to Chinatown, where Jewish history is hiding in plain sight. Near the entrance to the Manhattan Bridge, just south of Chatham Square, is the oldest Jewish cemetery in the U.S., at 55 St. James Place. The graveyard was used from 1682 to 1828 by Congregation Shearith Israel, also known as the Spanish and Portuguese Synagogue. Today Shearith Israel's synagogue is uptown at 2 W. 70th St., but the congregation was founded in the 1650s by Sephardic Jews who settled in Lower Manhattan when it was New Amsterdam, a Dutch colony. Emma Lazarus belonged to the congregation, as did her famous relative, U.S. Supreme Court Justice Benjamin Cardozo.

The St. James cemetery is one of three historic Shearith Israel graveyards located on lonely Manhattan sidestreets; the others are at 76 W. 11th St., used from 1805-1829, and on West 21st Street west of Sixth Avenue, used from 1829 to 1851. You can still make out dates and names in Hebrew and English on many tombstones. "It is indeed remarkable seeing these old cemeteries amidst all the buildings — silent tributes to our ancestors and a New York of days gone by," said Rabbi Hayyim Angel of Shearith Israel.

Heading north, where Chinatown runs into the Lower East Side, you'll find the Eldridge Street Synagogue, 12 Eldridge St., http://www.eldridgestreet.org. It was founded in 1887 as the first great house of worship built by Eastern European Jews in the U.S. In 2007, after a 20-year, $18 million restoration, a museum opened onsite about the synagogue and local Jewish history.

Nearby is the Lower East Side Tenement Museum, 97 Orchard St., http://www.tenement.org. The building dates to 1863, but it was a time capsule when the museum acquired it in 1996: Its apartments had been sealed off since 1935. Museum tours ($22) now tell the stories of the real people who lived there. The building housed immigrants from various countries and religious backgrounds, but several tours — one called "Hard Times" and another called "Sweatshop Workers" — focus on Jewish families. The museum also offers "Foods of the Lower East Side," a walking tour ($45) with tastings at neighborhood eateries like Kossar's Bialys, 367 Grand St., and The Pickle Guys, 49 Essex St.

Other worthwhile stops in the area include the Bialystoker Synagogue, organized in 1865 and housed in an 1826 fieldstone Federal style building at 7-11 Willett St.; and the Lower East Side Jewish Conservancy, which offers walking tours on New York Jewish history and operates a storefront visitor center at 400 Grand St. with interesting exhibits; http://www.lesjc.org.

During Hanukkah, the Chabad-Lubavitch Jewish outreach organization sponsors the lighting of a massive menorah, 32 feet tall, on Fifth Avenue and 59th Street near Central Park, Dec. 20-27. Candles are lit at 5:30 p.m., except for the Sabbath, with a 3:30 p.m. lighting Dec. 23 and 8:30 p.m. Dec. 24.

The Jewish Children's Museum, in Crown Heights, Brooklyn (792 Eastern Parkway, Kingston Avenue stop on the No. 3 train), offers hands-on interactive exhibits about holidays and culture along with a climbing wall for young children and a minigolf course. Kids can crawl through a challah bread tunnel, go shopping in a kosher supermarket and walk through the creation story from the Old Testament. A program on pressing oil for Hanukkah takes place Dec. 18-Jan. 1. Museum admission, $10; kids under 2, free; closed Friday-Saturday; http://www.jcm.museum.

Many visitors to the Jewish Children's Museum are from the local Lubavitch community but the museum gives a warm welcome to all and hosts 20,000 public school children a year in addition to families. Its mission is to promote tolerance; it was created in memory of Ari Halberstam, a local teen murdered in a 1994 terrorist attack.

On Manhattan's Museum Mile, the Jewish Museum at 92nd Street and Fifth Avenue is hosting "The Snowy Day and the Art of Ezra Jack Keats," a moving tribute to the beloved author of books like "Whistle for Willie." Keats was born Jacob Ezra Katz in Brooklyn in 1916 to Eastern European Jewish immigrants. The exhibit looks at how the poverty and anti-Semitism he experienced as a child influenced his work. Young visitors will enjoy a reading room inspired by Keats' stories.

The Jewish Museum is also hosting an exhibit of 33 Hanukkah menorahs chosen from its permanent collection by another favorite children's author, Maurice Sendak, who wrote "Where the Wild Things Are." Sendak, also born in Brooklyn to Jewish immigrant parents, lost much of his extended family in the Holocaust. The Keats and Sendak exhibits are on view through Jan. 29. Admission, $12; children under 12, free; closed Wednesdays; http://www.thejewishmuseum.org/.

Finally, if you're crazy about latkes (potato pancakes eaten during Hanukkah), head to the Brooklyn Academy of Music, Dec. 19 at 6:30 p.m. for the third annual Latke Festival, where top chefs compete to create the best latke. Tickets are $30; http://www.greatperformances.com/latkefest.

 


 

A Revolutionary Torah

Shearith Israel scroll, with burn marks still on it, is centerpiece of New-York Historical Society’s reopening exhibit.

Tuesday, November 15, 2011
Eric Herschthal 
Staff Writer

In August 1776, George Washington and his troops retreated to Manhattan Island. The British had just routed his rebel army in Long Island, and Washington tried desperately to hold onto what little perch of New York he could. But by November, the British expelled his army from Manhattan, which the British occupied throughout the Revolutionary war.

During the occupation, thousands of rebel sympathizers fled the city, and for good reason: British troops ransacked the city, setting fire to homes, bridges and even New York’s only synagogue.  Many members of the congregation — Shearith Israel, founded in 1729 and the only synagogue in New York for nearly a century — fled the city, too.

But at least one remarkable artifact survives from the congregation’s tumultuous Revolutionary years: a Torah scroll that still has burn markings on it, and that is now on display at the New-York Historical Society. It is being shown in a mini-exhibit called “The Resilient City,” along with four cityscapes by contemporary artist Richard Hass, as part of the society’s three-year, $65 million reopening. 

“Because the Torah scroll touches on so much of American history, and of New York history, we decided to show it,” said Debra Schmidt Bach, a curator at the society. In addition to the scroll, prominently displayed on first floor, Shearith Israel — whose current synagogue, built in 1897, is adjacent to the museum — lent dozens of artifacts from its own collection for an exhibit on the society’s fourth floor titled “Treasures of Shearith Israel.”

“Most people, when they think of Jewish immigration to New York, they think of the late-19th century” when the vast majority of the today’s New York Jews arrived, said Louise Mirrer, the president and chief executive officer of the New-York Historical Society. “But [Jews] were here for a long time, and were an important part of the city. … In order to tell that story we tried to get whatever we could from Shearith Israel.”

Some of the artifacts in the fourth-floor exhibit are evidence of the congregation’s deep roots in New York — or rather, New Amsterdam. The first Jews ever to set foot in North America immigrated to Manhattan Island before it was even a British colony. 

In 1654, 23 Jews arrived in New Amsterdam, a Dutch colony, fleeing what is today Brazil. The Portuguese had just ousted the Dutch from their South American colony, and Jews were no longer welcomed there. Most went back to Amsterdam or to the British Caribbean colonies, but a handful went to what is now New York.

“The people who showed up [in New Amsterdam] in 1654 arrived there not by choice, but by accident,” said Noah Gelfand, a historian of early American Jewry who teaches at the University of Connecticut and Hunter College. Not only were Jews forced to flee Brazil once the Portuguese took over, he explained, but the Dutch governor of New Amsterdam, Peter Stuyvesant, tried to expel them, too.

Stuyvesant had little success. New Amsterdam was essentially a commercial enterprise, and Jewish merchants played a small but significant role in the company that ran it, the Dutch West India Company. The company’s shareholders, several of them Jewish, ordered Stuyvesant to allow the 23 Jewish refugees to stay. 

“Peter Stuyvesant was basically told by his employers: ‘Back off,’” said Eli Faber, a leading historian of Colonial American Jewry. “But,” Faber added, “by 1660, those Jews disappear from the record [and] I feel there’s no conclusive way to explain why they left.”

Some may have left because of lingering ant-Semitism, but a more probable explanation, Faber speculates, is that business was not going well. Four major companies back in Amsterdam dominated Dutch trade, and they may have had a negative effect on the Jewish community’s chance for success. 

But there was at least one Jew who remained in the colony — Asher Levy — and the exhibit showcases a handwritten inventory from his shop. Dated from 1683 and written in fine cursive script, the list details many goods he bought and sold: beef, wheat, clothing, sugar; he even worked at times as a barber. “In those days, people didn’t specialize,” said Faber.

The Shearith Israel congregation that lives on today, however, probably dates to the early 18th century — despite the congregation’s claim to being connected to the original 23 Jews.  Scholars like Faber argue that there is simply no evidence that those first Jews stayed for long, and that a new wave of Jews from both Amsterdam and the British Caribbean colonies began arriving in the 1680s. 

There were around 100 Jews in Manhattan at the turn of the 18th century, and the first time the congregation’s name appears is in 1706. About 20 years later, the congregation built its first synagogue in Lower Manhattan, on today’s South William Street. To consecrate the occasion, it bought two Torah scrolls — one Sephardic, another Ashkenazi — since the community was split. And during the Revolution, the British attacked both scrolls, though it is the Ashkenazi one that is now on display.

“They set one on fire, and they slashed the other with a sword,” said Rabbi Hayyim Angel, the current rabbi at Temple Shearith Israel. Jewish law requires that desecrated holy texts be buried, but Angel and other scholars speculate that the community realized the historic value of the damaged scrolls and kept them instead. 

Of course, it is not entirely clear where the scrolls were kept during the seven years of the British occupation. Most of the Shearith Israel congregants fled the city, since they were rebel sympathizers; perhaps they took the scrolls with them. But another possibility is that that the British forces protected them. The British employed Hessian soldiers to help fight the war, and at least one of them in the city was Jewish, said Bach, the curator.

In any event, the pillage of the synagogue was probably not an anti-Semitic attack. “It was part and parcel of the vandalism that was going on throughout the city,” said Bach. Moreover, British commanders harshly punished the two British soldiers who attacked the synagogue. “One was lashed so severely he died from his wounds,” she added.

Shearith Israel keeps several artifacts from its long history on display at its current Upper West Side home, though most are kept in a storage facility. But this is the first time the burned scroll has been on display since 2004, when the congregation celebrated the 350th anniversary of the Jewish arrival in New York.

On the fourth-floor exhibit, several other prized possessions are on view. There is a circumcision registry that records male births from 1756 to 1787, and it shows how connected Jews were throughout the colonies and early states. The Shearith Israel mohel traveled to Connecticut and Rhode Island, the document makes clear, performing the Jewish rite.

Rare Judaica by the famed Colonial silversmith, Myer Myers, is also on display. He made his fame, and fortune, for non-Jewish colonials. But the congregation also commissioned him, and the exhibit features Sabbath candleholders and a Chanukah menorah by Myers. 

But items from the 19th Century can be seen as well: two portraits of Jews who fought in the War of 1812; relief aid pamphlets for Civil War soldiers, a campaign led by the congregation’s woman; even a book of poems by Emma Lazarus, a congregation member and revered writer whose poem, “The New Colossus,” adorns the Statue of Liberty.

It is her words — “Give me your tired, your poor, / your huddled masses yearning to breathe free” — that welcomed the hundreds of thousands of Jews fleeing Eastern Europe at the turn of the 20th Century. Those Jews came to define American Jewish life for the next century, and continue to do so. But few realize that Lazarus, a Sephardic Jew, had roots that went back to Colonial New York and its first congregation, Shearith Israel.

“They have a phenomenal collection,” Bach said of the congregation, “and their history is really an incredible part of American history.”

“The Resilient City” and “Treasures of Shearith Israel” opened on Nov. 11 at the New-York Historical Society, and will be on view for about four months. The museum is located at 170 Central Park West. (212) 873-3400.
 

 


 

Buried

Three cemeteries belonging to Shearith Israel, the oldest Jewish congregation in North America, are tucked away in Manhattan, a visible legacy of New York City’s long-ago Jewish past

By Adam Chandler|August 26, 2011 7:00 AM


Image

There’s a small Jewish cemetery tucked away on an unlikely block in Manhattan, behind some condominiums on West 21st Street. It’s just a few minutes from Tablet Magazine’s new office [1] on Tin Pan Alley, and I recently stumbled upon it. As it turns out, it has two siblings further downtown, and, taken together, the trio offer a window into the history of both the city and its Jewish community.

The three historic Manhattan cemeteries belong to Congregation Shearith Israel, a Spanish and Portuguese synagogue in Manhattan and the oldest Jewish congregation in North America, established in 1654. They are perhaps the most durable legacy of New York City’s long-ago Jewish past. The Shearith Israel congregation was founded by 23 Jewish refugees, descendents of Spanish Jews, exiled during the Inquisition, who fled from Recife, Brazil, after it was taken from the Dutch by the Portuguese. They were fleeing anti-Semitism but were greeted coldly by Peter Stuyvesant, the Dutch director-general of the colony of New Netherland. From 1654 until 1825, Shearith Israel was the only Jewish congregation in New York City. In its long history, membership of the congregation has included Supreme Court Justice Benjamin Cardozo, three founders of the New York Stock Exchange, and the poet Emma Lazarus [2], whose famous words from “The New Colossus” are affixed to the Statue of Liberty. Shearith Israel—the name translated is “Remnant of Israel”—owns a Torah that dates to the American Revolution.

The First Cemetery of Shearith Israel is in southern Manhattan, above the first neighborhoods of New York City; it is the oldest Jewish cemetery in North America. The lot sits near Chatham Square in Chinatown and is lined with the graves of, among others, 22 veterans of the American Revolution and the first American-born rabbi. It was once a place where residents of nearby tenements would hang up their wash, and its trees provided cover for George Washington to hide a battery of guns from the British during the American Revolution. The cemetery, which operated from 1683 until 1828, is now listed on the National Register of Historic Places.

If you walk north, in the direction the city grew, the Second Cemetery is easier to miss. It sits on a small tract on West 11th Street, just east of 6th Avenue, amid perfectly maintained Greenwich Village townhouses. Established in 1805, the cemetery was cut significantly in size when the expanding city built 11th Street on the city grid as a part of the Commissioners’ Plan of 1811.

Twenty headstones from the original Second Cemetery are still standing on 11th Street, beside an old red brick building that was once a Civil War tavern known as The Grapevine, where Union officers would carouse and Southern spies eavesdrop—the origin of the phrase “I heard it through the grapevine,” made famous a century later thanks, variously, to Gladys Knight, Marvin Gaye, and a cartoon box of singing raisins.

Of Shearith Israel’s three historic cemeteries, it’s the third that is the most visibly disjointed from its urban enclosure. Unlike the Second Cemetery, an elfin triangle tucked away on a small tree-lined street in Greenwich Village, or the First, which blends in with the nondescript stacks and ramshackle structures of Chinatown, the Third sits on an anonymous block of 21st Street, just west of 6th Avenue. The lot for the Third Cemetery was purchased in 1829 for the then-princely sum of $2,750. Like for the others, at the time of its purchase, the area surrounding the Third Cemetery was still considered to be the outskirts of New York City.

Buildings on three sides make the tract appear diminutive and boxy, like a missing tooth. Large black gates block public entrance from the street. The cemetery operated until 1851, after which a law was enacted forbidding burial anywhere south of Manhattan’s 86th Street. The Third Cemetery has about 250 graves, some of them still legible, others too effaced to read.

To the east of the graveyard once stood the third iteration of the Shearith Israel Synagogue. When the synagogue moved to its present location on an erstwhile duck farm on Central Park West, the old building became Hugh O’Neill’s Dry Goods Store. The O’Neill Building later came under the ownership of the El-Ad Group, an Israeli company whose American real-estate arm converted the building into condominiums, as it did with the Plaza Hotel after purchasing [3] the landmark in 2004. To the west of the cemetery stands another condominium. Nearby, on Seventh Avenue, is the storefront of New York’s newest Trader Joe’s, which is fittingly, among other things, a dry-goods store.

 

 

 

This Week in History: New York’s first synagogue

By MICHAEL OMER-MAN
08/04/2011
SynagogueThe first Jewish community to arrive in America consecrates their first synagogue 46 years before the revolutionary war.
 
On April 8, 1730, New York’s only Jewish congregation gathered in the heart of what is now Manhattan’s financial district to consecrate its first synagogue. The congregation of Shearith Israel, North America’s oldest to this day, would go on to influence the establishment of some of US Jewry’s most influential and lasting institutions in the New World.

In the fall of 1654, 23 Jews aboard the Santa Catarina arrived in what was then New Amsterdam from Recife, Brazil. Descendants of Jews who had fled the Portuguese and Spanish Inquisitions to The Netherlands, the small community had settled in Dutch colonies in South America. Fearing a repeat of the persecution they faced in Europe, the small community once again left their homes and sought refuge when the Portuguese recaptured Recife in 1654.

RELATED:
This Week in History: Vanunu convicted for treason
This Week in History: The Triangle Shirtwaist Fire

The Jews’ arrival in New Amsterdam, however, was not immediately hospitable. Like their ancestors in Eygpt, the future-congregation of Shearith Israel was forced to depart quickly and with few belongings. Upon arrival, the captain of the Santa Catarina sold their remaining effects at auction to pay for their fare. The local governor for the New Amsterdam Company, not thrilled by their arrival, wrote to his superiors asking that “none of the Jewish Nation be permitted to infest New Netherland.” In reply, however, the company described his request as “inconsistent with reason and justice,” the New York Times reported in 1899. Shearith Israel was henceforth given express permission to settle in the New World.

From its first days, the Jewish community of New York and its sister congregation in Providence, Rhode Island fully participated in the fledgling American project into which it was welcomed. Members of the Shearith Israel congregation fought in the American Revolutionary War against the British, including a colonel who served as an aid to General George Washington. Other notable Jews from Shearith Israel helped found the New York Stock Exchange and would serve on the US Supreme Court in later days.

After renting various spaces of worship for decades, in 1730 the members of Shearith Israel consecrated their first permanent synagogue on Mill Street in lower Manhattan (South William Street today). Until 1865, it was the only established Jewish congregation in New York but in the late 19th and early 20th century, the birth of several other Jewish streams, movements, congregations and institutions were highly influenced by Shearith Israel’s leadership and members.

One of the major splits and restructuring was greatly influenced by a failed experiment to bring a chief rabbi in order to unite and supervise New York’s growing and divided Jewish communities. In the nearly two centuries of Jewish presence in America, individuals and groups had sought different paths at reconciling the individualistic, capitalist and democratic spirit of the United States. Many saw Orthodox Judaism as a relic that belonged in the Old World.

In an attempt to counter this trend, several orthodox communities invited Rabbi Jacob Joseph to be the first chief rabbi of New York. Joseph, however, faced great suspicion and even disdain from liberal and Reform Jewish communities as well as non-religious and socialist Jews. His lack of fluency in English and “Old World” ways, in addition to economic resentment by poorer Jews over demands to support Joseph quickly doomed the new and short-lived position of chief rabbi. Even among the orthodox communities, the very leaders who brought him from Lithuania abandoned him. Joseph died several years later.

After Joseph’s death, the position of chief rabbi was dissolved and the experiment aimed at unifying American Jewry was abandoned. In light of the failure, the Orthodox Union was established as part of ensuing efforts to consolidate unification within orthodox communities.

Shearith Israel’s rabbi at the time, Henry Pereira Mendes, was one of the founders of the American Jewish Theological Seminary. After the death of Rabbi Joseph, he saw a need to build a more democratic consolidation of Orthodox Judaism. He soon left the JTS to help found the Orthodox Union. With his departure, however, JTS moved towards become one of the Conservative Movement’s (Masorti) central institutions.

A New York Times article from 1884 notes the growing split taking place in the synagogue, in which more reform-minded members sought to change the character of the congregation. Decidedly voting to remain an orthodox congregation, Shearith Israel has since been associated with the Orthodox Union.

Housed today in Manhattan’s Upper West Side, the congregation of Shearith Israel continues to be an important foundation of American Jewish history; it played a pivotal role in the establishment of various Jewish streams and institutions. The current synagogue – the congregation’s fifth – is a lauded architectural landmark built in the tradition of Portuguese Jewry. Its members are the descendants of America’s oldest Jewish community, established over 100 years before the United States, and its synagogue was the first permanent house of worship built by Jews in New York.

 


 

Cemetery Article Page 1

Cemetery Article Page 2

Cemetery Article Page 3

Cemetery Article Page 4

Open House at 21st Street Historic Cemetery

Click here for the video from DNAInfo


The Jewish Week, Wednesday, June 16, 2010
Rabbi Hayyim Angel. Michael Datikash
An Obligation To The Dead

 The oldest Jewish cemetery in the United States would probably be an official historical landmark site today, but no one knows where it’s located.

Shortly after the original group of 23 Jews from Brazil arrived in then-New Amsterdam in 1654, they founded Congregation Shearith Israel then successfully petitioned city authorities to establish a Jewish burial ground on “a little hook of land,” most likely on the sparsely developed island of Manhattan.

The site of that first Jewish cemetery is lost; Shearith Israel, the only Jewish congregation here from 1654 until 1825, set up a series of cemeteries over the subsequent years.

This week the congregation completed the first phase of renovations on an 80-by-120-feet patch of land in lower midtown that is known as the Third Cemetery but is really the fourth.

In a brief ceremony under an overcast sky and the branches of dogwood and crabapple trees, Rabbi Hayyim Angel of Shearith Israel read Hebrew blessings and spoke of “the religious obligation of cemetery upkeep.”

The ceremony marks the end of the initial, decade-long removal of debris and repair of gravestones in the site, usually locked, which is bordered on three sides by towering apartment buildings. A stone path cuts across the field of neatly cut grass and repaired gravestones.

Designer-educator Christine G. H. Franck explained  that the area was restored to look like it did in photos dating back to the 1930s.

The cemetery “has been transformed,” said Edward Kirkland, chair of the Community Board 4 landmarks committee “The stones were all over the place.”

Kirkland was part of a small group of invited participants that included preservation officials and descendants of Shearith Israel’s long-gone congregants.

“They are our spiritual ancestors,” Rabbi Angel said, pointing to the resting places of some 250 onetime members of the congregation. “Were it not for their efforts, we would not be here today as an organized committee.”

The cemetery on West 21st Street off of Sixth Avenue served as an active burial ground from 1829 until burials south of 86th Street were banned in 1852. Among the approximately 150 gravestones there are some from the 1700s, moved from the synagogue’s First Cemetery on St. James Place opposite Chatham Square.


Congregation Shearith Israel Welcomes Ireland's President Mary McAleese on May 23, 2010

Click here for video from Channel 11, WPIX

Click here for article from Ireland Independent

Click here for article from New York Times

163 Years Later, a President Visits to Say Thank You

image

Ozier Muhammad/The New York Times

Shearith Israel, where Mary McAleese of Ireland is coming.

By JIM DWYER
Published: May 21, 2010

Jacques Judah Lyons had a strong tenor voice, one that people were glad to hear in song or speech. One March night, he used it to challenge a crowd in Lower Manhattan. Strangers in a far-off place needed their help, he said, but he knew that members of his audience had principled objections. So many of their own people, they pointed out, other Jews right there in New York, were also destitute and needed assistance.

But were these objections real, he asked, or just “excuses which the lips utter while they are rejected by the heart?”

He was speaking in a synagogue on Crosby Street on March 8, 1847, where he was the chazan, or prayer leader. His subject was relief for people in Ireland who were starving to death in a famine caused by failures of crop and government. By the end of that evening, Mr. Lyons had collected about $200 from the congregation, Shearith Israel, according to an account in the April 1847 issue of The Occident, a monthly on Jewish subjects.

On Sunday, more than 163 years later, the congregation, now at 70th Street and Central Park West, will be visited by the president of Ireland, Mary McAleese. She will give thanks for the generosity of Shearith Israel and another New York congregation, Shaaray Tefila, during the famine years. About $1,000 for relief was collected by Jews in New York.

“In some of the conventional histories, the story of the contributions of the Jewish community here has been lost to sight over the years,” said Niall Burgess, the consul general of Ireland in New York.

The story, however, is part of the tradition at Shearith Israel, said Rabbi Hayyim J. Angel, the leader of the congregation. “I knew about this growing up,” Rabbi Angel said. “We speak about it all the time in the synagogue. Chazan Lyons made a fund-raising appeal on behalf of humanity, nothing to do with religion or race.”

The Irish famine, which ran from about 1845 to 1852, was among the first humanitarian crises to be reported in the early days of global media. People and religious groups from around the world responded with donations, as described by Christine Kinealy, a professor at Drew University, in the current issue of Irish America magazine.

The first major contributions came from Calcutta, where about 40 percent of the occupying British Army was Irish-born. The Choctaw Indians, who were displaced from their homelands in the southeastern United States earlier in the 19th century, sent $174 to Ireland. Money was raised from prisoners in Sing Sing, former slaves in the Caribbean, convicts on a prison ship in London, slave churches in the South. Major sources of donations included the Society of Friends and the British Relief Association, led by Lionel de Rothschild.

The famine began with a blight on the leaf of the potato, a staple of Irish tenant farmers, and accelerated through a system of absentee landlords and colonialism. The relief efforts became tangled in bureaucratic snares and rigid commitments by British authorities to free-market solutions. . Some evangelists saw an opportunity to swap soup for the conversion of Catholics.

But there was no such agenda for most of the donors, including Shearith Israel. The congregation was formed in 1654 by Spanish and Portuguese Jews who had been living in Brazil and were driven out. When 23 refugees reached New Amsterdam, the Dutch West Indies Company ordered Peter Stuyvesant to accommodate them, “provided the poor among them shall not become a burden to the Company or to the community, but be supported by their own nation.”

Mr. Lyons became the chazan in 1839. He helped found Jews Hospital, now known as Mount Sinai. His appeal in 1847 on behalf of the Irish bluntly stated that the Jews who gathered on Crosby Street had almost nothing in common with the people on the tiny island. “There is but one connecting link between us and the sufferers,” he said. “That link, my brethren, is humanity.” When Mr. Lyons died in 1877, his niece, Emma Lazarus — author of the “Give me your tired” inscription for the Statue of Liberty — wrote a verse in his honor, “to requite the just man’s service with a just man’s death.”

Mr. Burgess, the Irish government’s senior official in New York, learned about the gifts of the Jews here from a friend who saw some information about them in the Irish Jewish Museum in Dublin. Christine C. Quinn, the City Council speaker, connected the Irish officials with the Shearith congregation.

The congregation has continued its charitable works since 1847. The Irish are now among the leading donors of official development aid. Mr. Burgess said that was part of the famine legacy: “A few years back, President McAleese said, ‘We are a first world nation with a third world memory.’ ”

 

How New York's Jewish community tried to rescue Irish in Great Famine

President McAleese to hear how Jews raised funds for famine relief

By  APRIL DREW Irish Voice Reporter

Famine

A previously unknown act of kindness by the Jewish community in New York sending relief for the Irish Famine has been uncovered.

President of Ireland Mary McAleese, while visiting New York next week, will attend a ceremony at the Congregation Shearith Israel to mark the generosity of the New York Jewish community to the people of Ireland during the Great Hunger.

While people in Ireland were dying by the day because the potato crop failed in 1846, a Jewish reverend in New York reached out to his community and raised a substantial sum of money to help the Irish.  The money raised was in the $1,000 range, close to $82,000 in today’s money.

A newspaper report around the time stated that New York had contributed as much as $80,000 in total, and claimed that this was "about the same sum that has been contributed at home from all the wealthy classes of Ireland to the Central Relief Committee for all Ireland."

Reverend Jacques Judah Lyons held a meeting in his synagogue in Crosby Street on March 8, 1847, to gather financial support to help raise funds for Irish Famine relief.

Rabbi Hayyim Angel of the Congregation Shearith Israel located at West 70th Street told the Irish Voice on Tuesday that Lyons applied the teachings of the Torah when he reached out and helped the people of Ireland during their toughest era.

Money was also raised by the Temple Shaaray Tefila and an individual contribution of $500 was given by banker August Belmont (founder of Belmont Racetrack).

According to records from the March 8 meeting, Lyons told the gathering that its purpose was to “take measures for the relief of the famishing thousands of their fellow mortals in that unfortunate and destitute country, Ireland."

While Lyons, who was among those who founded the Jews (now Mount Sinai) Hospital, recognized that the Jewish community in New York needed dollars for its own internal needs, he insisted that his community reach out to help the people of Ireland.

When questioned about sending aid to those outside their own community, Lyons said, "It is true that there is but one common link between us and the sufferers...That link is humanity.”

He continued, “Its appeal to the heart surmounts every obstacle. Clime, color, sect are barriers which impede not its progress thither.”

Although it is not clear how much funds were actually sent to Ireland from the Jewish community, it is estimated to be about $1,000, a substantial amount at the time.

Angel said, “Reverend Lyons held a fundraising appeal at the Synagogue and had the money sent to Ireland for famine relief, and by doing so he aptly applied what the Torah teaches us about compassion and responsibility for all people, in this case he applied it to a far-away crisis.”

Angel said the ceremony to mark the New York Jewish community’s aid to Ireland in the mid 1800s is important because “according to Jewish tradition, there are two fundamental elements in commemorating events of the past.

“Remembering our shared memories helps build our identities and shared understanding.  More importantly, however, is that our memories inspire us to continue this beautiful legacy of humanistic concern that transcends boundaries of geography and religion,” said Angel.

Irish Consul General, Niall Burgess told the Irish Voice on Tuesday that there has been many stories both told and published about the Famine relief contributions from abroad, but very little has been written or known about the Jewish contributions during that era.

Burgess, through a friend, was made aware of the special relationship the New York Jewish community had with the Irish during the Famine through the Jewish Museum inDublin.

“There are some stories that are well known about Famine relief contributions, but when you look at some of the specialist works on that period the three Jewish contributions don’t feature very prominently,” said Burgess.

The event with McAleese is one of three being held on Sunday, May 23 to mark the Great Hunger.

After the commemorative ceremony at the synagogue, a Mass at St. Patrick’s Cathedral will be celebrated by Archbishop Timothy Dolan, and a later event at Battery Park will commemorate the hunger memorial.

Burgess said the event at the Congregation Shearith Israel is of particular significance.

“This story and others like it -- like that of the Choctaw Indians -- is the reminder of how when a humanitarian crises happens, how even in the mid-19th century, there is a sense that this just wasn’t our concern, it was everyone’s concern,” he said. 


06/06/2010 11:19 AM

Yeshivas Urged To Up Special Needs Enrollment

By: Lindsey Christ

Click here for video from Channel 1

Jodi and Gavin Samuels moved to New York from Australia so their children could attend Orthodox Jewish schools, and they planned to send their third child to the same Upper West Side yeshiva that their older children attend. But officials at the Manhattan Day School told them they wouldn't even interview two-year-old Caily.

Caily has Down syndrome, but her parents say she's not the only special needs child in their Orthodox community whose been rejected from local Jewish schools.

"Why is it that we are in one of the wealthiest communities in the world, yet there is no real option for Jewish children in our community to get a Jewish education?" said Jodi Samuels. "Why is it that Jewish kids are going to Catholic schools on the Upper West Side in one of the most densely populated Jewish cities? Why is it that 97 percent of children with Down syndrome are mainstreamed but my child with Down syndrome has no option to be mainstreamed if we want a Jewish education?"

The Samuels raised those questions, and others, in a recent public forum held at Congregation Shearith Israel and more than 170 people showed up to hear experts on special education and Jewish education speak. The panelists agreed many Orthodox schools need to do a better job of including special needs children.

"Our Jewish community has so much more to do to be more inclusive, to be more tolerant, to be more helpful," said Dr. Jeff Lichtman of the National Jewish Council for Disabilities.

Only a small fraction of the people attending the forum said they have a child with special needs. Most were just interested in learning more about the issue and discussing how the community should handle special education.

But not everyone has been supportive.

"We've received threats. We've been told we'll be squashed. We've had people attack us," Samuels said.

The Manhattan Day School never returned NY1's calls for comment, but the Samuels say they'll keep fighting for Caily to be considered. They've also offered to pay for any additional services needed to include her. But even as public schools are reorganizing so almost all special education students will be mainstreamed, the general consensus at the forum was that many Orthodox schools have a long way to go.


 

image

Video of Rabbi Hayyim Angel Speaking at Press Conference on April 20, 2010 for Jewish American Heritage Month

image


 

A Rabbi's Rabbi Shares His Seder Secrets
Rabbi Hayyim Angel
Published in The Jewish Press on February 10, 2010
http://www.jewishpress.com/pageroute.do/42505

The ideal drashah (sermon) combines science and art.
There is the scientific component, where the darshan embodies deep and authentic Jewish scholarship: breadth of knowledge, methodology, and faithfulness to tradition. Equally significant are the artistic elements of the drashah: eloquence, presentation, and a penetrating understanding of one's intended audience.
It is no easy feat to compose good Pesach sermons. One must envision creative twists to well-trodden ancient texts, emerging with new understandings that educate, inspire, and delight. 
As an accomplished scholar, and armed with a lifetime of experience as a community rabbi and then president and rosh hayeshiva of Yeshiva University, Rabbi Dr. Norman Lamm brings all his credentials as a master darshan to our Pesach Sedarim in his newly published commentary on the Haggadah, The Royal Table (OU Press). 
Perhaps the core philosophy of this treasure-trove of insights can be identified in Dr. Lamm's interpretation of the preface to the first half of the Hallel (Psalms 113-114), where we promise to sing a "new song" (shirah chadashah). 
Dr. Lamm expresses amazement that this "new" song is none other than "the old, tried, worn Hallel." His response: "Our people throughout the ages have instinctively understood that the rhythm of Torah combines the old and the new new insights are possible, insights that come with age and wisdom and experience . We must keep the old in sight; perceive in it the new through Insight; and as a result learn - to excite our souls and galvanize our spirits." 
That interplay between tradition and creativity receives magnificent expression throughout his elucidations of the classical Haggadah text. 
Dr. Lamm stresses that ethical living is central to Judaism: "The highest form of creativity is neither intellectual nor artistic; it is ethical." Elsewhere he even converts the korech sandwich into a lesson in balancing the different elements of our personalities - represented by the symbols of matzah and marror - to achieve perfection. Extremes must be avoided. 
There is a talmudic debate about whether we should begin the negative aspect of the storytelling from our physical slavery or from our idolatrous origins. Instead of tackling that debate, Dr. Lamm explores a more basic question. If the Talmudic sages cannot even agree on so fundamental a point, how can we ever speak about "tradition"? 
Dr. Lamm answers that uncertainty provokes machloket l'Shem Shamayim (debate for the sake of Heaven), and that uncertainty coupled with ongoing study makes life more interesting and energizing. 
Religious existentialism emerges in the discussion of the plague of darkness. Darkness and solitude can indeed be a plague, and this is how the Egyptians perceived it. However, one with a healthier perspective finds blessing in moments of solitude. Loneliness can be painful, but also can become a creative opportunity to hear the voice of God and discover ourselves.  
Dr. Lamm infuses ironic meaning into our practice of reclining. We recline as a relic from the Roman period, when nobles did so on couches while they dined. In an age of great technological advances such as chairs, however, of what value is this fossilized custom?  
Dr. Lamm responds that our Seder is profoundly lacking because there is no Temple, and it was the ancient Romans who destroyed it. We shall not allow that destruction to undo us as a people. 
Our response is to celebrate a living tradition from the era of the Temple with a Roman practice, while that once invincible Roman Empire is long gone.
               Along with his perspicacious discussion of the Four Children, Dr. Lamm delights the reader with another section that outlines traits of the Four Parents. Education should not be focused exclusively on children and their respective differences. Rather, our continuity as a people depends heavily on the religious-educational attitudes of parents and how they speak to their children. 
Dr. Joel Wolowelsky has provided an invaluable service in reading Dr. Lamm's sermons, selecting and abridging them, and placing them alongside the text of the Haggadah as a running commentary. He also has succeeded in retaining Dr. Lamm's authentic voice (as stated in the general introduction, Dr. Lamm reviewed the volume). 
The Royal Table is a veritable gold mine for rabbis and educators. In addition to the wealth of insight, it is a consummate model as to what makes a great drashah. The Royal Table similarly is a welcome addition for all committed Jews seeking to enhance their Sedarim and ultimately their personal religious growth. The book is accessible to Jews of all backgrounds, as Dr. Lamm combines his hallmark eloquence and subtlety with clarity and a keen understanding of a diverse Jewish community. 
            The Royal Table is a worthy bearer of the epithet shirah chadashah - a new song. In his capacity as master darshan, Dr. Lamm has discovered much that is new within the ancient text of the Haggadah, inspiring reflection, growth, and further discussion. A must read.

Hayyim Angel is rabbi of Congregation Shearith Israel of New York (the Spanish-Portuguese Synagogue, founded in 1654), and teaches advanced undergraduate Tanach courses at Yeshiva University. He has published two collections of studies in Tanach - "Through an Opaque Lens" and "Revealed Texts: Hidden Meanings."

 


 

Shearith Israel's Community Wide Yom Hashoa program (4-20-09) was featured on local television news reports recently:

WABC

NY1


 

New York Daily News Article


Forward Article

Merengue, Flamenco, and a Side of Latkes

By Matthew Oshinsky
Wed. Dec 24, 2008

CELEBRATORY: The quintet Ansambl Mastika performed at Hanukkah concert, held December 23 at New York's Spanish and Portuguese Synagogue.

It was standing room only as concertgoers filed into Congregation Shearith Israel, Manhattan’s Spanish and Portuguese Synagogue, for an evening of traditional Sephardic song. The December 23 event, part of the 4th annual Sephardic Music Festival — December 21–28 in New York — offered a tuneful lesson in the long and varied tradition of the music that originated, for the most part, on the Iberian Peninsula and traveled across the globe with Spanish Jews as they fled the Inquisition in 1492.

Congregants were still picking over the spread of homemade latkes and brownies when the Florida-based saxophonist Yehonatan Elazar began the evening with a roster of soft-jazz inflected tunes that fused Sephardic melodies with flavors of the Mediterranean and Latin America. Mr. Elazar jokingly apologized for injecting one of his compositions with a merengue rhythm — a product, he explained, of his Dominican heritage, and further testimony that Sephardic music, like the Jewish people, claims roots in nearly every corner of the globe.

As concert organizers restocked the food and jammed more chairs into the modest Levy Auditorium, the Israeli guitarist Dan Nadel and American vocalist Audrey Aviva Babcock took the stage to showcase their fine synthesis of Spanish, Middle Eastern, and European music.

“This music has a lot of ‘ay’ in it, which is Spanish for ‘oy,’” Ms. Babcock said of the duo’s repertoire, sketching a line of sorrow in song that began with 15th century Spanish Jews and gypsies, continued through the grand opera of George Bizet’s “Carmen,” and came to define, among other genres, the blues music that underpins much of our modern Western fare.

Clenching her fists and pulsing with the tremors of a diva, Ms. Babcock, her warm mezzo-soprano bounding from wall to wall, intoned tales of jealous lovers and dashed hopes in the anguished voices of Sephardim who were singing dirges long before the Christians ruled the Iberian Peninsula. She sang mostly in Ladino, an ancient, nomadic form of Spanish spoken by the Jews of the region that was nearly decimated after their expulsion.

Mr. Nadel laid an expert flamenco foundation for Ms. Babcock’s vocals, alternating furious strums of his acoustic guitar with dexterous flourishes up and down its neck. Later, he stirred in the slower arpeggiations of North American folk and the colorful chord structures of traditional gypsy music.

Moving from the soulful to the celebratory, the New York-based quintet Ansambl Mastika finished the program with a set of upbeat Balkan finger-snappers that managed to accomplish what the dwindling coffee supply could not. Led by the woodwind player/composer Greg Schneiderman (a.k.a. Greg Squared), the electric outfit set its feet in Eastern European folk music, weaving clarinet lines and blasts of trumpet into a tapestry that covered everything from Bulgarian wedding music to the big-band jazz of Benny Goodman (a first generation Polish-American Jew).

As members of the audience danced spontaneously through the aisles (okay, they were prodded), the abiding power of community that spawned each of the various strains of music on the program swelled like the warm heart of an ever-hopeful people.